Searching for a tagline since 2001

Site Search

previous post -- next post

Facebook Tries To Be Too Much

I have been actively using Facebook over the past few months and I have belonged to Facebook for years, mainly because almost my entire family is on there. I do enjoy keeping at least somewhat notified of what they might be doing. But also after using Facebook over this time I am not overly impressed with the interface. Facebook is much prettier than MySpace which should just die already, but the user interface on Facebook is still broken.

Facebook does not replace a blog, not if you actually want to write anything with any depth. The video sharing is not that great and the quality of the video saved is just barely acceptable. Photo gallery, it just does not really cut it in this category either. As far as a status updates, Twitter and my favorite Identi.ca are far superior. I view both Twitter and Identi.ca as being like a giant IRC channel allowing you to tune in and tune out whomever you choose. My first thought every time I check Facebook is that it is a cluttered mess. Maybe Facebook will find ways to remedy these issues, but for me they have a lot of work ahead.

Personally, the constant prompting spurred by my friend's use of every Facebook application under the Sun is very annoying. The utter onslaught of crap wanting access to my personal information makes it impossible to know if there are any Facebook applications that are worth using. I think everyone should be very wary of allowing each of these applications access to your personal information that may include your phone, email address and birth date to just name a few. I have mostly ignored all prompts, not because I do not care about some cause but because I have no wish to allow my personal information to be accessed by the owners of these applications.




Comments:
What is this?
I agree with all your points. I signed up for Facebook quite a while ago and have been using it a little bit over the last two months. It's the web-publishing equivalent of a kiddie pool, and even as powerful as its social networking is, it's a walled garden. I've only used it for status updates and have written on a few walls. Not a compelling experience when you're aware of richer, more open tools for doing all that stuff. Its convenience is probably a good part of the draw.

Commented by aharden @ Thursday, March 05, 2009


What is this?
I tend to agree too. I've recently started using Facebook more but Buff's right the application prompts are very annoying. I was wondering the other day though if anyone still uses classmates.com, with the ease of searching for classmates on Facebook that had to be a killer for a paid site.

Commented by swood @ Sunday, March 08, 2009


What is this?
Yeah, there is a reason Facebook is making money. Facebook just seems the logical choice to plan reunions and such. Like Alex said, powerful social networking, but a walled garden.

Commented by Scott @ Monday, March 09, 2009


What is this?
Agree completely. MySpace is an example of everything that should NOT be done as far as web design goes. Facebook is definitely a classmates.com killer if you ask me. I've found so many people from school on FB which is very nice.

But FB tries to be everything, without doing anything in a superior way. That seems to be the way things go. You can have something does one thing great, like Flickr for example which shares photos in a GREAT way. But when you try to do everything with one app/site your bound for failure.

Commented by Jonathan @ Wednesday, March 11, 2009


Name:

Email (will never be published):

url:

Comment:

coffee or beer  Scott likes to drink?
Buy Scott a Drink